Devoted warrior Colonel Budanov. Yuri Budanov: biography, family, murder. Why Yuri Budanov was convicted Hero of the Chechen War Colonel Budanov

In 1998-2000 commanded the 160th Guards Tank Regiment, which took part in the Second Chechen War. In December 1999, he personally organized and carried out an operation to rescue 150 soldiers of the 84th separate GRU special forces battalion who were surrounded near the village of Duba-Yurt. In 2003, the North Caucasus District Military Court found him guilty of the kidnapping and murder of 18-year-old Chechen girl Elza Kungaeva. He was sentenced to 10 years in prison. The investigation and trial of Yuri Budanov had a great public outcry. He was released on parole in January 2009. On June 10, 2011, he was shot dead by Magomed Suleymanov in Moscow, who, according to the investigation, was associated with the so-called Lazan criminal group, headed by Khozh-Akhmed Nukhaev.

Biography

Born on November 24, 1963 in Khartsyzsk (Donetsk region, Ukrainian USSR) in the family of a blacksmith. In 1981 he was called up for military service in the USSR Armed Forces, serving in Poland. In 1987 he graduated from the Kharkov Guards Higher Tank Command School. He served in military service in Hungary and Belarus. In 1995-1999 he studied at the Military Academy of Armored Forces named after. Marshal R. Ya. Malinovsky.

During the period of hostilities against illegal armed groups in the Chechen Republic in January 1995, he received a brain concussion due to a landmine explosion.

In August 1998, he was appointed commander of the 160th Guards Tank Regiment, and in January 2000 he was promoted to colonel. In October and November 1999, Budanov was wounded twice when a shell exploded and when a tank was fired at from a grenade launcher.

Candidate Master of Sports in Sambo. Married, father of two children.

Budanov case

Arrested on March 27, 2000 on charges of kidnapping, rape and murder of 18-year-old Elza Kungaeva. The charge of rape was dropped after examinations and testimony from the participants in the case.

Budanov served his sentence in the 11th detachment of the correctional institution YUI 78/3 in the city of Dimitrovgrad, Ulyanovsk region.

In May 2004, Yuri Budanov filed a petition for pardon. On September 15, 2004, the pardon commission granted his request. The governor of the Ulyanovsk region, Vladimir Shamanov, signed a petition for pardon. The commission's decision caused protests from a number of politicians, human rights activists and journalists. On September 21, 2004, a rally was held in Grozny at which a protest against the pardon was expressed. Ramzan Kadyrov said: “if this pardon of Budanov occurs, we will find an opportunity to give him what he deserves.” On September 21, 2004, Budanov withdrew his request for clemency.

In November 2006, Budanov filed a petition for parole with the court of the Ulyanovsk region, but the request was denied.

On December 24, 2008, the court granted Yuri Budanov’s request for parole. On January 15, 2009, Budanov was released.

Work at State Unitary Enterprise "EVAZhD"

After his release, Budanov got a job as the head of the passenger car fleet of the State Unitary Enterprise "EVAZhD" (for the operation of high-rise buildings). He showed strictness towards his subordinates. Budanov settled in the house of the Administration of the President of the Russian Federation. This apartment was previously provided to his family with the assistance of General V. Shamanov.

Murder

The day after the murder, the Emir of the Caucasus Emirate, Doku Umarov, made a brief statement, in which he expressed satisfaction with the liquidation of Colonel Budanov and warned that “the same fate awaits all criminals who are involved in bloody crimes in Chechnya and the Caucasus.”

According to the Kommersant newspaper, on August 30, 2011, well-known religious figure Magomed Suleymanov was arrested on suspicion of Budanov’s murder. The publication reports that a witness identified the detainee, and fingerprinting and genetic examinations were ordered. M. Suleymanov completely denies his involvement in the crime

Funeral

The funeral service for former Colonel of the Russian Armed Forces Yuri Budanov took place in the Church of the Holy Unmercenaries and Wonderworkers Cosmas and Damian in Khimki. The closed coffin with Budanov's body was taken out of the church, carried around it, then loaded into a car. The funeral took place at the central cemetery of Khimki.

Yuri Dmitrievich Budanov was buried at the Novoluzhinsky cemetery in the city of Khimki, next to the Soviet pilots who died during the Great Patriotic War. (According to other sources, Budanov is buried not next to the grave of the Soviet pilots-Rodionov Memorial, but on the outskirts of the cemetery.)

Versions of murder

Riyadus-Salihiin Statement

On July 23, a message appeared on the Kavkaz-Center website in which the sabotage and terrorist group Riyadus-Salihiin took responsibility for the murder of Budanov.

Budanov’s own opinion

According to Budanov’s former cellmate, entrepreneur Oleg Margolin, convicted of economic crimes, Yuri Budanov himself confidentially told him:

Awards

• Order of Courage (awarded in 1999, deprived of the award in 2003).

Family

Wife - Svetlana Vyacheslavovna. Children: son - Valery, lawyer, reserve lieutenant, daughter - Ekaterina (at the time of Budanov’s murder - 23 years old and 11 years old, respectively). Father - Budanov Dmitry Ivanovich. Mother - Budanova Valentina Valentinovna.

According to NTV, after his release from prison, Budanov lived in the near Moscow region.

Memory

The following poems are dedicated to Yuri Budanov:

• “For the oath” by Leonid Efremov.
• “They say about him: he was a real warrior...” Petra Kuznetsov.
• “Colonel Kurtkin”, poem by Alexei Shiropaev.
• “To the Russian Hero” by Alexander Kharchikov.
• “The Murderous Theme”, a poem by Dmitry Bykov from the project “Citizen Poet”.
• “On the Death of a Colonel”, poem by Georgy Topchiyants.

24.11.1963 - 10.06.2011

Yuri Dmitrievich Budanov was born on November 24, 1963 in the city of Khartsyz, Donetsk region, Ukrainian SSR.

In 1987 he graduated from the Kharkov Guards Higher Tank Command School. Supreme Soviet of the Ukrainian SSR, in 1999 (in absentia) - Combined Arms Academy of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation.

After graduating from college, he served for three years as part of the units of the Southern Group of Forces on the territory of Hungary, and then in the Byelorussian SSR; After the collapse of the USSR, he continued to serve in the Russian Federation.

In October 1998, he was appointed commander of the 160th Guards Armored Regiment, stationed on the territory of the Trans-Baikal Military District (since December 1998 - the united Siberian Military District).

Since September 1999, together with the regiment, he took part in military operations on the territory of the Chechen Republic.

In January 2000, he was awarded the Order of Courage and received (early) the rank of colonel.

On March 30, 2000, Yuri Budanov was arrested by officers of the military prosecutor's office on charges of kidnapping, rape and murder of 18-year-old Chechen Elza Kungaeva.

During the investigation, Budanov testified that, considering a resident of the village of Tangshi-Chu Kungaeva to be a sniper of one of the gangs, he ordered his subordinates to deliver the girl to the regiment, after which - during interrogation - he strangled her, since Kungaeva allegedly resisted and tried to take possession of the weapon. Subsequently, Budanov, without denying the fact of the murder, insisted that he acted in a state of passion.

On February 28, 2001, in the North Caucasus District Military Court (Rostov-on-Don), the trial began in the case of Budanov, who was charged with crimes under Articles 126 (kidnapping), 105 (murder) and 286 (abuse of official powers) of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation .

In July 2001, the North Caucasus District Military Court announced a break in court hearings in connection with a psychiatric examination of Budanov at the State Scientific Center for Social and Forensic Psychiatry named after. V.P. Serbsky (Moscow). In October of the same year, after passing the examination, Budanov was transferred back to Rostov-on-Don.

On December 16, 2002, an expert opinion was announced in the North Caucasus District Military Court, according to which Budanov was declared insane due to the consequences of shell shock.

On December 31, 2002, the North Caucasus District Military Court adopted a decision to release Budanov from criminal liability and send him for compulsory treatment, but on February 28, 2003, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation recognized such a decision as unfounded and made in violation of substantive and procedural law and sent the case is being reviewed again (however, the preventive measure against Budanov remains the same - detention in a pre-trial detention center in Rostov-on-Don).

On July 25, 2003, the North Caucasus District Military Court found Budanov guilty of abuse of office, as well as the kidnapping and murder of Kungaeva. According to the court ruling, Budanov was stripped of his military rank and the Order of Courage and sentenced to ten years in prison to be served in a maximum security colony (when sentencing, the court took into account Budanov’s participation in the counter-terrorism operation and the presence of minor children), after which he was transferred to a colony YuI 78/3 (city of Dimitrovgrad, Ulyanovsk region).

On May 17, 2004, Budanov submitted a petition for pardon to the President of Russia, but on May 19 he withdrew it. The reason for the recall was the uncertainty with Budanov’s citizenship, since he was drafted into the USSR Armed Forces back in 1982 from the Ukrainian SSR (On May 21, 2004, Budanov was given a passport as a citizen of the Russian Federation).

On September 15, 2004, the Ulyanovsk regional pardon commission granted Budanov’s new request for clemency, but this decision led to protests from the Chechen public, as well as a statement by the head of the government of the Chechen Republic, Ramzan Kadyrov, that if Budanov was released, “we will find an opportunity to reward him.” according to his deserts,” and on September 21, the convict was forced to withdraw his petition.

Subsequently, the courts several more times - on January 23, August 21, 2007, April 1 and October 23, 2008 - denied Budanov parole, until on December 24, 2008, the Dimitrovgrad court of the Ulyanovsk region made a decision on his conditional release. -early release.

In Chechnya, this court decision caused numerous protests.

On June 9, 2009, it became known that Yuri Budanov was interrogated as a suspect in a criminal case regarding the murder of residents of Chechnya. According to the Russian Federation Investigative Committee, in 2000, 18 residents of the Chechen Republic were illegally deprived of their liberty at a checkpoint located near the village of Duba-Yurt, Shalinsky district of the Chechen Republic. Three of them were subsequently found killed. A number of local residents claimed that Yuri Budanov was involved in committing this crime.

On June 10, 2009, the Investigative Committee of the Prosecutor's Office announced that Budanov had been cleared of suspicion of murdering residents of Chechnya. According to the materials of the Investigative Committee, Budanov testified that he could not physically be at the checkpoint located near the settlement of Duba-Yurt, Shalinsky district of the Chechen Republic during the periods of time when 18 residents of Chechnya disappeared there without a trace. Budanov's testimony was confirmed by the materials of the criminal case.

RIA NEWS

In October and November 1999, when a shell exploded and when firing at a tank from a grenade launcher, he twice suffered brain contusions.

On December 31, 1999, when the President of Russia abdicated power, Russian intelligence officers, Chechen fighters in the “negotiated” village of Duba-Yurt, and three kilometers away “silently” our tanks, following the order of the chief of staff of the “West” group, Major General Alexei Verbitsky, not to interfere during a secret operation.

They - 20 people out of more than a hundred - were saved only because two of Colonel Budanov’s subordinates violated the order: the officers, when they realized that the reconnaissance company was simply being killed and there was no smell of any secret operation there, sent their tanks to Duba-Yurt.

At first, Budanov’s track record was no different from thousands of others like him. The standard officer ladder slowly stretched upward: commander of a platoon, company, battalion, the first Chechen war, the first shell shock... Everything changes dramatically on the eve of the second Chechen war, when 36-year-old Lieutenant Colonel Budanov, having graduated in absentia from the Academy of Armored Forces, accepts the position of commander of a separate tank regiment (almost 100 tanks). A month and a half later, the regiment was moved from Transbaikalia to Chechnya, under the command of the commander of the Western Group of Forces, General Shamanov. “Russian General Ermolov,” as Shamanov was enthusiastically called then, liked the young and promising regiment commander.

Very quickly Budanov receives the rank of colonel and the Order of Courage. And soon the country will recognize its heroes by sight: the front page of “Red Star” is decorated with Budanov’s photographic portrait. The regiment gains a lasting reputation as the best in the group. (Komsomolskaya Pravda, 2002)

The most important thing is that Budanov passed half of Chechnya with negligible losses. Just one dead driver! No other commander could boast of this. But at the end of December fighting began in the Argun Gorge. The task of Budanov’s regiment is to take three dominant heights. Here the successful colonel suffered his first losses.

It is difficult to maintain discipline in an army that has stopped. Budanov did this according to his own understanding: he yelled at his subordinates, occasionally throwing phones and anything else he could get his hands on at them. They say that the door to his kung was riddled with bullets, because the colonel had adopted the fashion of shooting if someone came to him without knocking.

One day Budanov witnessed how a contract soldier pointed out to a comrade Major Arzumanyan who was passing by: “Brother, shoot this “chock” with a cigarette... The Colonel became furious. Having beaten the soldier on the spot, he immediately went to his tent and brought the beaten man a carton of cigarettes: “This is for you to smoke, son.” And remember, you cannot call an officer a “chock.”

“I don’t consider him a scumbag,” says the colonel’s lawyer Anatoly Mukhin. - A servant, a patriot... The concepts of “honor, army, readiness to close the embrasure if the Motherland needs it” are not an empty phrase for him even now. Do you know what Shamanov nicknamed him? Water carrier. For constantly dedicating a regimental vehicle to bring drinking water to Tangi-Chu. And under Budanov, on his own responsibility, he opened the passage for three and a half thousand refugees to the regiment checkpoint, although he had strict orders not to do this. I just realized that this could turn into a riot..."

Budanov’s condition became depressing after heavy fighting in the Argun Gorge, where many of his fighting friends were killed by snipers. Budanov was sent on vacation. His family noticed drastic changes in his behavior - irritability, nervousness, constant headaches, unmotivated outbursts of rage. He constantly cried over the photographs of his dead friends, vowing that he would find “that same sniper.”

Former commander of the 58th Army of the North Caucasus Military District, General Vladimir Shamanov about Budanov. “He never hid behind the soldiers. It happened that in order to eliminate sniper beds (they were located in the cemetery of the village of Duba-Yurt, occupied by militants), Budanov broke forward in a tank with a crew, without additional escort. He was everyone's favorite because he never paid for a single successful operation with a soldier's life. This was his commandment." (Russian News, 2001)

Poem

They say about him: he was a real warrior,
A Russian soldier for his Little Russia.
- Forgive me, brother, that you became guilty,
In Russia, the Tsar is the one most to blame.

They bypassed Russia,
They caught the firebird by the tail,
And from under the explosions he wrote funerals,
And life was shattered on the sniper’s nose.

Your path is marked with orders and gunpowder,
And let someone express a different thesis.
You were, they say, responsible for Russia,
And he slept sweetly behind your back.

Colonel Yuri Budanov (biography presented in the article) is one of the most controversial figures of our time. Some perceive him as a hero, dedicating poems and songs, while others perceive him as a rapist and murderer who mocked a defenseless Chechen girl on his daughter’s birthday. What is known about this man today?

The path to the army

Yuri Dmitrievich Budanov, whose biography the article is devoted to, is a native of Ukraine. His homeland is the small town of Khartsyzsk, which is located in the Donetsk region. The boy was born in 1963, on November 24, into a military family. He practiced sambo and received the title of Master of Masters. He grew up as an ordinary teenager who dreamed of serving in the army. He was called up in 1981 while serving military service in Poland.

Not finding himself in civilian life, in 1987 he entered a military school. I chose a tank one, which is located in the Ukrainian Kharkov. The tank driver was Dmitry Ivanovich, Budanov’s father. Upon graduation, the young man served in Hungary. The collapse of the USSR found him in Belarus, where the officer made a difficult decision for himself - not to swear allegiance to the newly-minted republic, but to return to Russia.

He continued his service in Transbaikalia, where for 10 years he had no complaints; on the contrary, he was promoted to the rank of lieutenant colonel ahead of schedule. He entered the military academy, graduating in 1999.

Was there any participation in the First Chechen Campaign?

Did Yuri Dmitrievich Budanov take part in the hostilities? The officer's biography was collected by the press literally bit by bit. According to media reports, Budanov was already wounded in the First Chechen War, receiving a severe concussion. In 1999, two more will be added to it - already during the Second Chechen War.

Today, information has been published about the available documents, according to which Budanov did not take part in the first military campaign, and the information about the shell shock in January 1995 is false. At the moment, his medical record, which could shed light on a lot, is lost. According to the latest version, this was the work of Budanov himself, who tried to hide a certain diagnosis when submitting documents for admission to the military academy.

Yuri Budanov: Colonel saves special forces

Since October 1998, the officer has been appointed commander of the 160th armored regiment, which was transferred to the united Siberian Military District in December. Since the fall of 1999, his regiment was stationed in Chechnya, where it carried out orders regarding the neutralization of large gangs in the Argun Gorge and Khankala.

Why do many people perceive Budanov as a hero? This is due to the battle near Duba-Yurt at the end of December 1999, where a reconnaissance group under the command of Art. Lieutenant Shlykov ("Nara") was ambushed by militants. Special forces moved to rescue the Taras assault detachment, which allegedly came under fire at the Wolf Gate. Subsequently it turned out that the fighters of Art. Lieutenant Tarasov did not transmit any distress calls. It was an action radio game.

Neither the artillery (there was poor visibility due to thick fog) nor the soldiers of other assault brigades who came under fire could help the Nara. Having lost three units of armored vehicles, more than 10 people killed and 40 wounded, the reconnaissance group could have been completely destroyed if not for the tanks of V. Pakov’s battalion from the 160th regiment of Yu. Budanov.

Details and consequences of the rescue

Vladimir Pakov in two cars (a third joined in the evening) headed to the Wolf Gate, without having a direct order. That is why the crew personnel consisted exclusively of officers. Subsequently, it turned out that other units could have provided assistance, but the commanders were afraid of punishment for unauthorized actions, unlike Yuri Budanov.

The colonel saves a dying reconnaissance group, taking responsibility upon himself. It was with his consent that Vladimir Pakov, who learned about the tragedy, went to help the special forces. The tankers were stationed just three kilometers from the battle site.

According to the participants in the battle, without the help of the T-62 and Budanov’s officers, the remnants of the Nara would not have been able to get out of the ring of fire at the Argun Gorge on their own. The militant detachment was completely destroyed only a few weeks later.

The special forces were under the impression that the massacre was made possible due to the betrayal of the command. This fact was not officially confirmed, but the savior was declared a service discrepancy. Be that as it may, in January 2000, Yu. Budanov was nevertheless awarded the Order of Courage. There is information that he was nominated for this award twice, but the officer was not destined to receive it a second time.

Tragedy of March 26, 2000

This ill-fated day radically changed the future of Yuri Budanov. The Colonel became a father for the second time. His little daughter was born, who was named Ekaterina. Alcohol appeared on the table of the regiment commander and his deputy I. Fedorov. The rioting officers first gave the command to fire at the peaceful village, but Lieutenant Bagreev did not obey the order. Then Budanov decided to deal with Elsa Kungaeva, a Chechen woman who turned 18 shortly before the incident.

According to the colonel himself, she was suspected of having allegedly fought as a sniper on the side of the militants. The BMP crew was ordered to deliver the girl to the regiment's location. During an hours-long interrogation, Budanov strangled Kungaeva, breaking her spine. After which the body, according to him, was handed over to the soldiers. They abused her, which was proven by forensic examination.

Budanov's arrest

Already on the 27th it became known: Colonel Yuri Budanov was arrested. The hero’s biography ended here, the investigation and long trial of the criminal began, as he was recognized by the North Caucasus District Court. The ex-regiment commander was charged with three crimes:

• abuse of power;
• kidnapping;
• murder.

Initially, participation in rape was also charged. Subsequently, the charge was dropped, and the guilt of a soldier named Egorov was proven. Surprisingly, by a lucky chance he managed to avoid punishment, because the State Duma declared an amnesty. In January of the following year, Budanov's case was transferred to a military court, and the hearing itself began in February.

Officer's testimony

What version of what happened does Colonel Yuri Budanov himself present? The biography of his subsequent period of life is well presented in the media. Both his testimony at the trial and the stories of eyewitnesses, including cellmate Oleg Margolin, with whom the former officer had conversations for a long time, were studied.

According to him, the owner of the house (Kungaeva’s father) kept weapons, and his daughter repeatedly went to the mountains to shoot with a sniper rifle. It was hot during the interrogation, so Budanov unfastened his holster and put it on the table. The girl admitted to hating the federals and confirmed the assumption of the regiment commander.

He was about to hand her over to the scouts when she grabbed the pistol lying on the table. At the same time, she threatened Budanov that she would find his little daughter in order to “wrap her guts around a machine gun.” The combat commander, in a state of passion, which was later confirmed by an examination, strangled Kungaeva. Having come to his senses, the officer took the body out to the soldiers so that they could bury it. During the exhumation, it turned out that the girl was still alive for some time. During her lifetime, she was subjected to bullying and violence.

The court's decision

For many, Yuri Budanov is a hero of Russia. The biography of the ex-colonel shows: in July 2003, he was found guilty on three counts and sentenced to 10 years in prison.

It should be admitted: during the trial by a commission of experts in December 2002, a verdict was made about the officer’s insanity. The consequences of his shell shock, according to experts, could lead to a partial loss of control over his actions.

The case could have ended in forced treatment, but a few months later this decision was overturned by the Supreme Court of Russia. The colonel was stripped of his military ranks and government awards and banned from holding leadership positions for the next three years. The former officer was sent to a colony in the city of Dimitrovgrad (Ulyanovsk region) to serve his sentence.

Serving a sentence

In May 2004, former Colonel Yuri Budanov first filed a petition for clemency. He sent it personally to V. Putin, but soon withdrew it. Presumably, because of the position of R. Kadyrov, the President of Chechnya, who called the former officer an enemy of his people.

In the same year, a second petition followed, submitted by Budanov to the regional commission. Under it was the signature of Vladimir Shamanov, the then governor, formerly the commander of a group of troops of the Russian Ministry of Defense in the Chechen Republic. The commission returned military awards and military rank to the colonel. However, his participation in satisfying the governor's clemency petition received publicity. This led to a scandal, after which the request was again withdrawn.

At the beginning of 2007, Budanov applied directly to the court for parole. And he was refused, because he considered: “the prisoner did not repent of what he had done.” There were several more requests, but only in December 2008 a positive decision was made. The Dimitrovgrad court finally recognized that the criminal repented and fully atoned for his crime. Budanov's release took place in January 2009. He spent nearly 9 years in prison.

Life in freedom

Ex-Colonel Yuri Budanov arrived in Moscow, where his family was waiting for him. Thanks to the patronage of General Shamanov, he was given an apartment not just anywhere, but in one of the buildings of the Administration of the President of the Russian Federation. He managed to meet his father, who was seriously ill, but waited until his son returned from the colony. He soon died.

Budanov got a good job working on the passenger car fleet of the State Unitary Enterprise "EVAZhD". However, a month after his return, the Investigative Committee at the Chechen Prosecutor’s Office announced an investigation into the former colonel’s involvement in the murder and abduction of three more people in the Shali region.

According to their information, witnesses pointed to Budanov after stories about him on television. Subsequently, the number of victims in this criminal case increased to 18. Only in June 2009 was it announced that the former officer’s involvement in the disappearance of civilians was not confirmed.

Yuri Budanov: biography, cause of death

It was 2011. On the calendar - June 11. Together with his wife Svetlana, Budanov approached the notary's office, where the couple had to draw up documents for 11-year-old Ekaterina to travel abroad. The couple has two children. The eldest Valery was already 23 at that time.

Here, on Komsomolsky Prospekt, a bloody murder will be committed, which will be described in detail by CCTV footage. After a telephone conversation on the porch of the house, Budanov headed towards the central part of the yard, followed by a man whose identification mark was a baseball cap.

At 12:04, several men ran out to the sound of gunfire. Five shots were fired. Three were aimed at the head, two at the body. Yuri Budanov had no chance to survive. The criminal was found based on an identikit. He turned out to be a Chechen named Yusup Temirkhanov, whose father died at the hands of the Russian military. The man said the main motive for the murder was revenge. His photo is presented below.

Funeral of ex-colonel

Surprisingly, experts do not really believe in the Chechen trace, although R. Kadyrov, with his statements, actually gave indulgence to anyone who would deal with the killer of 18-year-old Kungaeva. Yuri Budanov himself warned about this (biography, cause of death are described in this article). The ex-colonel told his cellmate that he was afraid not of revenge from the girl’s relatives, but from those who want to erase the shameful pages of the events in Chechnya.

The former officer was buried at the Novoluzhinskoye cemetery, located on the territory of Khimki. He was taken on his last journey, given military honors, although no official representatives of the Ministry of Defense were present at the coffin. Several thousand people, among whom were many former and current officers, accompanied their comrade in arms in complete silence, not allowing the funeral to be turned into a political rally.

A few words about the family

His wife Svetlana walked the entire path of life with her husband, giving her husband two children. When Budanov was in a pre-trial detention center in Rostov-on-Don, she and her children visited him twice a month, although she was forced to move to Ukraine and live with relatives. Only in recent years has the family been provided with housing on a rental basis. Svetlana does not hide the fact that she had to accept the help of many people, including General Shamanov.

Having witnessed a crime, she found herself under state protection. Her ex-husband’s colleagues did not abandon her in trouble either, providing all possible support. They claim: about people like Budanov they say: “Soldiers respect, enemies fear.”

The eldest son Valery is a graduate of the Suvorov Military School. He received a law degree and works at the bar. Since 2011 he has been a member of the Liberal Democratic Party.

The youngest daughter Ekaterina still has everything ahead. In March, the girl celebrated her eighteenth birthday. For the family, an example of a real hero is their father, Colonel Yuri Budanov. His biography will be rewritten, they believe, and the name of the Russian officer will definitely be rehabilitated.

Parole of Budanov

Former Russian army colonel Yuri Budanov, sentenced to 10 years for the kidnapping and murder of 18-year-old Chechen Elza Kungaeva in 2000, is being released on parole.

This wild story shook the whole country: according to the Chief of the General Staff Anatoly Kvashnin, Colonel Budanov, who was participating in the counter-terrorism operation, raped and killed an eighteen-year-old girl, a resident of the village of Tangi. They say that Vladimir Putin himself ordered this fact to be made public and the officer severely punished, and for the first time the military command hastened to wash dirty laundry in public. However, the progress of the investigation into this barbaric act was terribly classified - the military prosecutor’s office seemed to have taken too much water in its mouth. Versions have emerged: maybe he didn’t rape? Or maybe he didn’t kill at all? Or maybe it was a Chechen sniper? Someone justified the colonel, someone branded him with the last words - what actually happened was not known. Now MK has learned all the details of that fateful day. We return to this terrible topic to dot the i’s.

Sunday, March 26, at the headquarters of the 160th Guards Tank Regiment, located near the village of Tangi (4 km south of Urus-Martan), promised to be fun. The war was ending for the Trans-Baikal tank crews - they would soon return to winter quarters.

However, the main reason was not the joy of the upcoming return home - it was not tomorrow yet. On the 26th, regiment commander Yuri Budanov celebrated his daughter’s second birthday. The booze, given the young colonel’s addiction to alcohol (he was assigned early two months ago), promised to be grandiose.

We sat down at the table in the field officers' mess at lunchtime, at two in the afternoon. The entire command of the regiment gathered: the “cap” himself and his deputies - Lieutenant Colonel Arzumanyan, chief of staff Lieutenant Colonel Fedorov, armed man Lieutenant Colonel Bobryakov, teacher Major Silivanets, rear officer Lieutenant Colonel Selikhov. All yours. The presence of four officers from the administration of the Siberian Military District, who came to the regiment for an inspection, did not bother anyone - after all, they gathered in the war, after battles, when it was not a sin to drink. Again, the old army rule: whoever doesn’t drink can get pawned, which means everyone should drink. And a lot. The pace was set by Yuri Budanov, whose health God did not harm - a bottle to the commander is like pellets to an elephant. They drank to the commander’s daughter, to the commander himself, to his fallen comrades, so that they wouldn’t raise a third toast to themselves. And then off we go.

To be fair, we note that officers who had gone on a spree sometimes took time away from the festive table. Colonel Budanov visited neighboring Tangui twice to have fun. He burst into the village in three combat vehicles and carried out “cleansing operations” there with searches of houses and detentions of local residents. There was neither an order from the headquarters nor a request from the higher command to carry out the “operation”, the Colonel was driven by fighting fervor and a thirst for revenge on all Chechens without parsing. At the same time, it was necessary to replenish supplies of alcohol that was quickly running out.

It is useless to look for vodka among the Chechens; Sharia law prohibits them from drinking alcohol. The head of the village administration, Shamil Dzhambulatov, who tried to explain this, was punched in the face. The regiment commander, who did not like that “some Chechen” was trying to object to him, beat the head in the presence of the village residents and his guards from the communications company.

The fun at headquarters continued. By seven in the evening, the chief of staff was itching to fight. Lieutenant Colonel Ivan Fedorov asked the commander for the go-ahead for a fire strike on the village of Tangi: “Dmitrich, let’s hire the Czechs, what are they doing there? For the purpose of, so to speak, testing combat readiness.” Budanov was kind: “Mochi, Ivanovich, why feel sorry for them!”

The staggering chief of staff wandered off to carry out his combat mission.

- 3-volley at the enemy with fragmentation p-p-pli! Fire, your mother! - Lieutenant Colonel Fedorov raged at the location of the reconnaissance company, whose guns were to erase the regimental commander’s resentment towards the disrespectful Chechens.

The acting reconnaissance commander, Senior Lieutenant Bagreev, seeing the state of the regiment's command and what orders were being given to him (the intelligence officer knew better than others that there were no armed militants in Tangi), ordered shots fired not with fragmentation, but with cumulative shells - in order to avoid casualties from the side local residents. But Fedorov, although he was drunk, realized what shells were flying into the village. Snatching a knife, he rushed at the senior lieutenant with an oath. He wisely moved away from the sight of the chief of staff, fortunately in such a state he could not chase him.

They punished the obstinate elder through joint efforts. Bagreev was summoned to headquarters, where he was brutally beaten by the regiment commander and chief of staff himself. Having been satisfied, Colonel Budanov ordered the reconnaissance company commander to be tied up by the soldiers of the commandant's platoon and thrown into the zindan - a deep hole covered with barbed wire on top. Bagreev stayed there for about a day.

By nightfall the drinking began to subside - they could no longer drink and fell asleep. The regiment commander continued to stay awake. Alcohol always had an exciting effect on him, Budanov became aggressive and hot-tempered, his subordinates tried at such moments (and lately the colonel drank almost every day) not to catch his eye. Around one in the morning he was tired of sitting in the headquarters, where his drinking buddies were snoring and there was no new entertainment. The commander ordered the BMP to be “mounted”: “We’re going to Tangi,” he explained to the crew of the combat vehicle with tail number 391, who were already accustomed to Budanov’s unexpected drunken antics. The visit to the village was short-lived - they took the girl. Budanov noticed eighteen-year-old Elsa Kungaeva during previous “cleansing” operations. They did not stand on ceremony with the “Chechen bitch”; she was snatched from the house, thrown inside an infantry fighting vehicle and brought straight to the commander’s trailer.

What happened in the regiment commander’s carriage on that fateful night is not worth describing - such stories are not for the faint of heart. In the dry language of the investigation, “while intoxicated, Yu.D. Budanov raped and killed citizen E. Kungaeva.” The fact of rape was confirmed by a forensic medical examination.

It was all over by four o'clock in the morning. Budanov called the crew of BMP number 391 and ordered the body to be taken away and buried. “It’s all in the water, and not a word to anyone, otherwise...” he breathed fumes into the faces of the stunned soldiers. The girl’s body was taken three kilometers from the regiment’s location and buried in the ground...

The stormy ending to this story came the next day. The hangover among the participants in the feast was severe - everyone knew that something terrible had happened, but they were afraid to find out the details. At this time, the headquarters of the “West” group had already learned from local residents what had happened in the tank regiment of Colonel Budanov. Still not believing in the possibility of such a wild act and hoping in his heart that all this would turn out to be at least half untrue, Major General Gerasimov flew to Tanguy. The very first minute showed that the general’s hopes were in vain. In a state of passion, Budanov denied his involvement in the murder of the girl with a pistol in his hand. He pointed his weapon at General Gerasimov and threatened him with death - it seems that the colonel was afraid to admit to himself a terrible crime.

Then he unexpectedly shot himself in the leg with a pistol. The chief of staff Fedorov, who had not yet sobered up, took the shot as a signal to action - he alerted the reconnaissance company and ordered the regiment commander to be surrounded and protected with his chest from the officers from General Gerasimov’s group. It seemed that just a little more and he would give the order to shoot to kill... At least that was okay.

Colonel Yuri Budanov, chief of staff Lieutenant Colonel Ivan Fedorov and the BMP crew were arrested. The war machine of investigation, punishment, prevention, follow-up and reassurance began to work. Conversations were held with soldiers and officers, at the meeting the criminal actions of the commander and chief of staff were condemned, work was organized to clear the surrounding roads and fields, local residents and the family of the deceased were provided with food assistance (I can imagine how much flour and gasoline was sent out!). As a result, on behalf of the residents and administration of Tanga, a letter was sent to the Minister of Defense “with a request to consider the conflict settled.”

In general, everything is over, and now, presumably, it is subject to oblivion. Until some Budanov makes a new trick. It's easier. There is no need to strain and do something with the army fighting in Chechnya. There is no need to pay attention to the physical and psycho-emotional fatigue of officers and soldiers, to their mental trauma and reactive state, which can push them to commit a crime. Not only in Chechnya, but also after the war, after many years, as it happened and still happens with the “Afghans”. Combatant syndrome - a person cannot leave the war.

From the forensic medical examination report conducted by experts of the 124th Central Laboratory of Medical and Forensic Identification of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, dated March 28, 2000: “The burial site is an area in a forest belt, 950 meters from the unit’s command post. The corpse of a completely naked woman, wrapped in a blanket (plaid), was discovered. The corpse lies on its left side, legs tucked to the stomach, arms bent at the elbows and pressed to the body. The perineum in the area of ​​the external genitalia is stained with blood, the blanket in this place is also covered in blood. A forensic medical examination of Kungaeva’s corpse was carried out on March 28, 2000 from 12 to 14 o’clock on the outskirts of the village of Tangi-Chu in sufficient natural light by the head of the medical department of the 124th laboratory, captain of the medical service Lyanenko V. The woman’s corpse is 164 cm long...

On the external genitalia, on the skin of the perineum, on the back surface of the upper third of the thighs, there are moist dark red smears, similar to blood with mucus... There are bruising radial linear tears on the hymen. In the intergluteal fold there are dried red-brown marks. 2 cm from the anus there is a rupture of the mucous membrane, up to 3 cm long. The tear is filled with coagulated blood, which indicates its intravital nature. On the blanket, on the side facing the corpse, there is a wet stain of a dark brown color, similar to blood, measuring 18x20x21 cm. The stain is located on the section of the blanket adjacent to the crotch area of ​​the corpse. The following were delivered along with the corpse: 1. Woolen jacket. The back is torn (cut) vertically along its entire length... 3. The T-shirt is worn. The back of the T-shirt is torn (cut) along its entire length. 4. The bra is worn. On the left, from the back, cut (torn) across the entire width. 5. Worn panties. On the inside, in the crotch area, they are contaminated with dry dark brown and yellow spots, similar to traces of feces and urine...

The tears in the hymen and rectal mucosa found on Kungaeva’s corpse were caused by the insertion of a blunt, hard object(s) into the rectum and vagina. It is possible that such an object could be a tense (in a state of erection) penis... ...the free end of the handle of a small sapper shovel could also serve. At the same time, the experts came to the same conclusion that the damage to the hymen and rectal mucosa discovered during the examination of the corpse was intravital...”

CLOSING INDICTMENT

in relation to Colonel of military unit 13206 Yuri Dmitrievich Budanov, accused of committing crimes under paragraph “c” of Part 2 of Art. 105; Part 3 Art. 126; p.p. “a”, “c” part 3 art. 286 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation,

and Lieutenant Colonel of military unit 13206 Ivan Ivanovich Fedorov, accused of committing crimes under paragraphs. “a, b, c” part 3 art. 286 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation

THE PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION established:

Budanov Yuri Dmitrievich On August 31, 1998, he was appointed to the position of commander of military unit 13206. On September 16, 1999, Fedorov was appointed to the position of chief of staff - deputy commander of military unit 13206. On September 19, 1999, Budanov and Fedorov went on a business trip to the Chechen Republic for participation in a counter-terrorist operation. On March 26, 2000, military unit 13206 was at its temporary deployment point on the outskirts of the village of Tangi, Urus-Martan district of Chechnya. During lunch in the officers' mess of the regiment, Budanov and Fedorov drank alcohol on the occasion of the birthday of Budanov's daughter. At 19 o’clock, Budanov and Fedorov, with a group of regiment officers and at Fedorov’s suggestion, arrived at the location of the regiment’s reconnaissance company, the commander of which was Senior Lieutenant R.V. Bagreev. Having checked the internal order in the unit’s tents, Fedorov suggested that Budanov check its combat readiness. Having received permission, Fedorov decided, without notifying Budanov, to give the command for the combat use of the company’s standard weapons in the village of Tangi. At the same time, the decision to open fire by Fedorov was made regardless of the developing situation, without any real need, since there was no fire on the positions of the federal troops from Tanga. Implementing his plan, grossly violating the requirement of the General Staff of the RF Armed Forces of February 21, 2000 No. 312\2\0091, prohibiting the use of reconnaissance units without comprehensive training and verification of their readiness to carry out combat missions, Fedorov gave the order to take up firing positions and open fire on the outskirts of Tanga.

Three combat vehicles took up combat positions. After occupying the firing lines, some of the company’s crews did not carry out Fedorov’s order to open fire on the populated area. Being annoyed by the refusal of his subordinates, Fedorov began to demand from Bagreev that he get his subordinates to open fire. Not satisfied with Bagreev’s actions, Fedorov jumped onto one of the BRM-1Ks and demanded that the gunner of Warrant Officer Larin’s vehicle open fire to kill. The personnel opened fire. As a result of the execution of Fedorov’s order and a shell hitting house 4 on the street. Zarechnaya village of Tangi, owned by a resident of this village, A.A. Javatkhanov, worth 150 thousand rubles, the house was destroyed.

While near the regiment's communications center, Budanov, having heard shots in the area where the reconnaissance company was located, ordered Fedorov to cease fire and called him to his place. Upon arrival, Fedorov reported to Budanov that Bagreev deliberately did not carry out the order to open fire. By order of Budanov, Bagreev was summoned to him. After Bagreev’s arrival, Budanov rudely began to make claims to Bagreev regarding the fact that he did not promptly comply with Fedorov’s order to open fire. Budanov began to insult him, and then punched Bagreev at least twice in the face. At the same time, Budanov and Fedorov ordered the commandant platoon personnel to tie up Bagreev and place him to serve his sentence in a hole dug in the unit’s location. At the same time, Budanov grabbed Bagreev by the uniform and threw him to the ground. Fedorov kicked Bagreev in the face with his booted foot. The arriving personnel of the commandant's platoon tied up Bagreev, who was lying on the ground. Next, Budanov, together with Fedorov, continued beating Bagreev, who was lying on the ground. At the same time, Fedorov struck Bagreev, who was lying on the ground, with his foot, shod in army ankle boots, at least 5-6 strong blows to the body, including the face; Budanov struck Bagreev with his feet, shod in army ankle boots, at least 3-4 blows to the body.

After the beating, Bagreev was placed in a pit, where he was in a sitting position with his hands and feet tied. 30 minutes after beating Bagreev, Fedorov returned to the pit, and jumping there, punched Bagreev at least twice in the face. The beating of Bagreev was stopped by regiment officers who ran up to the pit. A few minutes later Budanov approached the pit. On his orders, Bagreev was taken out of the pit. Seeing that Bagreev managed to untie himself, Budanov again ordered the commandant’s platoon personnel to tie up Bagreev. When this command was executed, Budanov, together with Fedorov, began to beat Bagreev again. Having finished the beating, on the orders of Fedorov and Budanov, Bagreev, with his hands and feet tied, was again placed in the pit. When Bagreev was already in the pit, Fedorov jumped into the pit and bit Bagreev on the right eyebrow. Bagreev sat in the said pit until 8 a.m. on March 27. 2000, from where he was released by order of Budanov.

At the 24th hour of March 26, Budanov, without instructions from the leadership of the higher headquarters in charge of the counter-terrorism operation, decided to personally go to Tangi. To check the information he had about his possible presence in house 7 on the street. Zarechnaya persons participating in illegal armed groups (illegal armed groups). To leave for Tangi, Budanov ordered his subordinates to prepare the BMP-1KSh 391 for departure. When leaving, Budanov and the crew members armed themselves with standard weapons, AK-74 assault rifles. At the same time, Budanov notified the BMP crew consisting of sergeants Grigoriev, Egorov, Li-en-shou that they were going to detain the female sniper. For this reason, the crew members subsequently unquestioningly followed his orders and commands.

At one o'clock in the morning on March 27, Budanov arrived in Tanguy. By order of Budanov, the BMP was stopped near house 7 on the street. Zarechnaya, where the Kungaev family lived. Budanov, together with Grigoriev and Lee-en-shou, entered the house. There was Elza Visaevna Kungaeva, born March 22, 1982, along with four minor brothers and sisters. Their parents were not in the house. Budanov asked where the parents were. Having not received a response, Budanov, continuing to exceed his official powers, in violation of Art. 13 Federal Law “On the fight against terrorism”, ordered Li-en-shou and Grigoriev to capture Kungaeva Elsa. Grigoriev and Lee-en-shou, believing that they were acting lawfully, captured Kungaeva and, wrapping her in a blanket taken from the house, took her out of the house and placed her in the landing compartment of the BMP 391. After the kidnapping, Budanov delivered Kungaeva to a location in / Part 13206. By order of Budanov, Grigoriev, Egorov, Li-en-shou brought Kungaeva, wrapped in a blanket, into the KUNG (unified cargo body) - the room where Budanov lived, laying her on the floor. After that, Budanov gave them orders to stay near the KUNG and not allow anyone in.

Left alone with Kungaeva, Budanov began to demand from her information about the possible whereabouts of her parents, as well as information about the routes of movement of the militants to Tangi. Having received a refusal, Budanov, not having the right to interrogate Kungaeva, continued to demand from her the information he was interested in. Since Kungaeva refused all of Budanov’s demands to provide information about the militants, Budanov began to beat Kungaeva, punching and kicking her multiple times in the face and various parts of the body. Kungaeva tried to resist, pushed him away, tried to run out of the KUNG.

Budanov, being sure that Kungaeva participated in an illegal armed group and was involved in the death of his subordinates in January 2000, decided to kill her. To this end, Budanov, grabbing Kungaeva by the clothes, threw her onto the trestle bed and, grabbing her neck with his hand, began to forcefully squeeze her neck. Realizing that by squeezing Kungaeva’s neck in this way, he would deprive her of life, wishing for her death, Budanov continued to forcefully squeeze Kungaeva’s neck with his hands until he was convinced that she showed no signs of life. Only after that did he stop squeezing the victim’s neck. These deliberate actions of Budanov resulted in a fracture of the right greater horn of the hyoid bone in Kungaeva, the development of asphyxia in her and her subsequent death. Realizing that he had committed the premeditated murder of Kungaeva, Budanov summoned Grigoriev, Egorov and Li-en-shou to his KUNG and ordered her body to be taken out and secretly buried outside the unit. This instruction from Budanov was carried out by the crew of BMP 391. Kungaeva’s body was secretly taken out and buried in one of the forest plantations, which Grigoriev reported to Budanov on the morning of March 27, 2000.

The accused Budanov and Fedorov, being interrogated in connection with this criminal case, partially admitting their guilt in the acts incriminated to them, changed the testimony they gave at the initial stage of the investigation.

ACCUSED BUDANOV YURI DMITRIEVICH

Questioned as a witness on March 27, 2000, Budanov explained that on March 25 he went to Tangi. He discovered mines in one of the houses and detained two Chechens. Giving an explanation about the circumstances of the conflict with Senior Lieutenant Bagreev, Budanov noted that no one beat Bagreev. When checking the combat readiness of the reconnaissance company, which he carried out together with Fedorov at about 19:00 on March 26, 2000, the company incorrectly acted on the command “to fight.” A conflict arose; Bagreev insulted Fedorov in an obscene manner. Then he ordered the arrest of Bagreev. Budanov denied the fact that Fedorov gave the command to fire at Tanga and the fact that fire was opened. At the end of the interrogation, Budanov submitted a petition that he wanted to write a confession about the deprivation of life of a relative of citizens who took part in bandit formations on the territory of the Chechen Republic.

Volume 3, l. 104-113

Further, in his own hand on March 27, 2000, Budanov, in a confession addressed to the military prosecutor of the North Caucasus Military District, stated the following. On March 26, 2000, he left for the eastern outskirts of Tanga with the goal of destroying or capturing a sniper. Arriving in Tangi at 0:20 a.m., I went into a house on the outskirts. There were two girls and two guys there. When asked where her parents were, the eldest daughter replied that she did not know. Then he ordered his subordinates to wrap this girl in a blanket and take her to the car. When they arrived at the unit, the girl was brought into his KUNG. Left alone, he asked the girl where her mother was. He, Budanov, knew from operational information that her mother was a sniper for the militants. The girl replied that she did not know Russian well and did not know where her parents were. To this he replied that she should know where her mother was and how many Russians she had killed. The girl started screaming, biting, and struggling. He had to use force. A struggle ensued, as a result of which he tore the girl’s jacket and bra. The girl continued to struggle, then he had to throw her onto the trestle bed and begin to choke her. He strangled her by the throat with his right hand. He did not remove the lower part of her clothes. After about 10 minutes she calmed down, he checked the pulse in her neck. She turned out to be dead. Budanov called the crew, ordered the body to be wrapped in a blanket, taken to a forest plantation in the area of ​​the tank battalion, and buried.

Volume 3, l. 114—115

Interrogated on March 28, 2000 as a suspect, Budanov testified that on March 3, 2000, he learned from operational sources that a sniper lived in Tangi. She fights on the side of the militants and he was shown her photograph. He learned all this from one of the residents of Tanga, who had personal scores with the militants. The same resident showed him around March 13-14, 2000, the last house on the eastern outskirts of the village where the sniper lived. On March 24, 2000, he drove past this house, but did not enter the house. On March 26, he drove up to this house. According to the information he had, the sniper was supposed to be at home on the night of March 26-27. He entered the house. No one was sleeping in the house; everyone was dressed. Budanov asked where the owner of the house was, the older girl replied that she did not know. Then he ordered his subordinates to take her with them. Having taken the girl, they returned to the regiment's location and he and this girl were left alone in his KUNG. The girl began to scream, insulted him with obscene language and tried to run away from the KUNG. He grabbed her and pushed her onto the bed. At the same time, he tore her jacket. Having dragged her to the far corner of the KUNG, he threw her onto the trestle bed and began to strangle her with his right hand by the Adam’s apple. She resisted and as a result of this struggle he tore her outer clothing. She calmed down after about 10 minutes. After she calmed down, he checked her pulse, there was no pulse. I called the crew to KUNG, and the crew commander and telegraph operator came in. At that moment, the girl was lying in a KUNG in the far corner, undressed, she was only wearing panties. He gave those who entered the task of wrapping her in the blanket in which she was brought and taking her out.

3rd Battalion and bury. He, Budanov, was infuriated that she did not say where her mother was and, according to the information he had, her mother killed 12 soldiers and officers with a sniper rifle on January 15-20, 2000 in the Argun Gorge.

Volume 3, l. 119—124

Having been interrogated on March 30, 2000 as an accused, Budanov pleaded guilty in part and testified as follows. On March 23, 2000, he detained two Chechens. 60 pieces of 80mm were seized from the house where they were located. min. One of the Chechens, Shamil, agreed to show Budanov the houses where the militants lived if they released him. Putting a soldier's hat on Shamil's head, he put him in an infantry fighting vehicle and drove with him through the village. It was Shamil who showed the house on the eastern outskirts of Tanga where the sniper lives. In addition, they were shown 5 or 6 houses where militants live. From Shamil, he, Budanov, learned that the sniper often comes home at night. That the sniper has a daughter who constantly informs her about Russian military personnel. Budanov partially changed his testimony about Kungaeva’s behavior, saying that she said that they would get to him, that he and his subordinates would not get out of Chechnya alive, began to use obscene language at his mother, and then ran to the exit. Her last words completely infuriated Budanov. He managed to grab her by the jacket and threw her onto the trestle bed. Next to the trestle bed stood a table on which his pistol lay. She tried to take the gun with her hand. Having thrown her onto the trestle bed, he held Kungaeva by the throat with his right hand, and her hand with his left, so that she could not take the gun. She began to struggle, as a result of which all her outer clothing was torn. He didn’t remove his hand from her throat, and after 10 minutes she calmed down.

Volume 3, l. d. 127-136; volume 4, l. d. 1-18, l. d. 19-38; 55—68

During additional interrogation on September 26, 2000, the accused Budanov specified his testimony about how he knew that the Kungaevs participated in an illegal armed group. He received such information from one of the Chechens with whom he met in January-February 2000 after the fighting in the Argun Gorge. This Chechen gave him a photograph in which Kungaeva was photographed with an SVD rifle.

Volume 4, l. 69-89

Being interrogated on January 4, 2001, Budanov testified that he did not admit his guilt in the abduction of Kungaeva. He believes that he acted based on the information he had. When he saw Kungaeva Elsa, he identified her from a photograph that he had. When he gave the command to Grigoriev and Li-en-shou to detain Kungaeva, he detained her in order to hand her over to law enforcement agencies. He did not do this, hoping to independently find out from the detainee where the militants were and take measures to detain them. He understood that if the militants found out about Kungaeva’s detention, they would take all measures to free her. It was for this reason that I decided to go straight to the regiment. In addition, all long-distance travel at night is prohibited. He was moving in the regiment’s area of ​​responsibility, where he was allowed to move. He does not admit his guilt in premeditated murder, since he did not want her death, he was in a highly excited state and it is difficult to explain how it happened that he strangled her.

Volume 4, l. 117—124

ACCUSED FEDOROV IVAN IVANOVICH

Questioned on April 3, 2000 as a witness, Fedorov testified that on March 26, 2000, he, Arzumanyan and Budanov went to check the internal order in the reconnaissance company. Having completed the check, he conveyed the introductory message to Bagreev - “attack the command post, occupy the firing line” and indicated the place where the firing line would be. After this, he called Bagreev to his place and asked why the combat vehicles did not stand on the firing line. Bagreev doesn’t remember what he answered. In response to these explanations, he most likely responded to Bagreev with obscene language. Then he began to grab Bagreev by his clothes. Budanov and Arzumanyan went to the regiment's command post. He does not remember who gave the command to tie Bagreev’s hands and feet, but the soldiers of the commandant’s platoon tied Bagreev’s hands. Then he approached Bagreev and struck him several times. He doesn’t remember how he beat him. Then Bagreev, on his, Fedorov’s, command, was put in a hole. Having jumped into the pit, he wanted to tell Bagreev everything he thought about him. Arzumanyan pulled him, Fedorov, out of the pit. He learned that Budanov went to Tangi at night after arriving at the commission unit from the headquarters of the “West” group. Somewhere on March 20, 2000, he saw Budanov’s photocopy of a photograph of a woman who, according to Budanov’s explanations, was a sniper. According to Budanov, this woman lived in Tangi and he must find her. This woman appears to be no more than 30 years old. Somewhere on March 25, 2000, Budanov went to Tangi and the Chechen showed the houses where the militants lived.

Volume 9, pp. 117-121

An examination of Fedorov’s workbook established that on the back of sheet 8 there is an entry - Sambiev Shamil, then it is written - Zaretskaya St., building 7, Khungaev Idolbek. The sheet was added to the case as evidence.

Volume 9, l. 138—142

Having been interrogated based on the notes in the work notebook, Fedorov testified that on page 8 it was written that it was Shamil Sambiev who indicated the addresses in Tangi where the militants lived. Two addresses were recorded, since the Chechen did not know the other addresses and indicated the houses visually. In total they were shown 10 houses.

Volume 9, l. 135—137

Having been interrogated on November 24, 2000, Fedorov testified that on March 26. 2000, he, Fedorov, gave Bagreev the command “to fight, the enemy is from Tanga,” after which he began to observe the actions of the scouts. Bagreev duplicated this command. Then he, Fedorov, saw that Bagreev’s actions were illiterate. First, he reprimanded Bagreev and tried to explain what mistakes he had made. Fedorov flared up. Then he obtained from Bagreev the correct implementation of the actions of the personnel in the combat crew. After this, seeing that the check showed the company commander’s poor orientation in the situation, he decided to fully check how the company could carry out the task of fire destruction. To do this, he gave the command to Bagreev - one shell per vehicle - at a separate building on the outskirts of Tanga "Fire". His decision to open fire on this house was also influenced by the fact that the unit was repeatedly monitored from this house. Regarding the conflict with Bagreev, Fedorov admitted that he was offended that he was so mistaken about the person and these thoughts seemed to push him to further actions.

Volume 9, l. 183—187

Being interrogated on December 26. 2000, Fedorov said that he did not agree that the house was valued at such an amount - 150 thousand rubles. This house, before the opening of fire on it on March 26, was significantly destroyed due to the fact that in December 1999, massive fighting took place between federal troops and gangs on the outskirts of Tanga. Before opening fire, he knew for certain that there had been cases of shelling of unit positions from the area of ​​this house.

Volume 9, l. 157—169

Meanwhile, the guilt of Budanov and Fedorov in the acts accused of them, in addition to their partial admission of guilt, is confirmed by the totality of evidence collected in the case.

VICTIM KUNGAEV VISA UMAROVICH,

Born 04/19/1954 married, Chechen, agronomist from Urus-Martanovsky, father of Kungaeva Elza Visaevna, testified as follows. Elsa was the eldest among the children in the family. Besides her, there are four more in the family. Elsa's character was very modest, calm, hardworking, decent, and honest. All housework was assigned to her, since his wife was sick and she could not work. For the same reason, Elsa was responsible for caring for the younger ones. She spent all her free time at home, didn’t visit guests, didn’t communicate with boys. Elsa was shy around males. I did not enter into intimate relationships with them. The daughter was not a sniper, she was not a member of any gangs - this is simply absurd. 26.03. In 2000, he, his wife and children went to the polls and began to do household chores. The wife began to get ready to visit her brother Alexei in Urus-Martan and left at about 3 p.m. He was left alone with the children. We went to bed around 21:00, because... there was no light. He was relaxing on the sofa in the summer kitchen. At about 0.30 on March 27, he woke up from the roar of a combat vehicle. She stopped in front of their house. He looked out the window and saw some people heading towards their house. He called his eldest daughter Elsa and asked to quickly get all the children up, dressed and taken out of the house, telling her that the house was surrounded by the military. He, Kungaev, ran out into the street and ran to his brother, who lived 20 meters away. At this time, his brother was already running towards him and began to run into the house through the central gate. Further, from the words of his brother, he knows that when he entered the house, he saw Colonel Budanov - he recognized him, because. Previously, his photograph was published in the Krasnaya Zvezda newspaper. Budanov asked: “Who are you?” Adlan replied that he was the brother of the owner of the house. Budanov rudely answered his brother: “Get out of here.” Adlan jumped out of the house and started screaming. From the words of the children, he, Kungaev, learned that Budanov then ordered the soldiers to take Elsa. She screamed, and wrapped in a blanket, she was carried out into the street. In connection with this incident, relatives immediately came running and began to raise everyone to their feet to find their daughter. I turned to the head of the administration, the military commandant of the village and the Urus-Martan region. In the morning at 6.00 we arrived by car in Urus-Martan to take measures to search for our daughter. By the evening of March 27, 2000, they learned that Elsa had been killed. In his opinion, Kungaev, Budanov kidnapped Elsa and then raped her because she was a beautiful girl.

Volume 2, l. 19-30, 71-74

Witness Magamaev A.S. showed that he is a neighbor of the Kungaevs. The family lived poorly. They worked mainly in the fields. I knew Elsa from birth. She grew up shy and did not communicate with male peers. He can say with confidence that Elsa never participated in gangs.

Volume 2, l. 78-80

Investigatively, any involvement of Kungaeva E.V. to illegal armed groups or its participation in illegal armed groups could not be established.

Volume 10, l. 26-30, 39-41

Questioned as a witness, Ivan Aleksandrovich Makarshanov, a former soldier of military unit 13206, testified as follows. In the evening of 26.03. The commandant's platoon of 2000 was alerted. Then, at the command of the regiment commander, the personnel of the commandant's platoon tied up the reconnaissance company commander. Bagreev, the reconnaissance company commander, was lying on the ground. Budanov and Fedorov inflicted at least three kicks on Bagreev’s body each, everything happened very quickly. After this, Bagreev was placed in a hole - the so-called “zindan”. After some time, when it was already dark, he heard screams and moans and left the tent. I saw that in the hole where Bagreev was placed (the tent was at a distance of 15-20 meters from the zindan) there were Budanov and Fedorov. Fedorov struck Bagreev in the face. Budanov was nearby. Someone shined a flashlight into the hole, so he saw everything clearly. Then someone pulled Fedorov out of the hole. Until 2 a.m. on March 27, he, Makarshanov, was in Fedorov’s tent, heating the stove. At about 1 o'clock in the morning I heard an infantry fighting vehicle drive up to Budanov's KUNG, and he watched what was happening from behind the curtain of the tent. He saw 4 people walking towards Budanov’s KUNG (one of them was Budanov). One was carrying something like a package on his shoulder, the size of a person’s body. He, Makarshanov, saw that long hair was hanging from one end of the bundle, the kind usually found on women or girls. The one who carried the package opened the doors, carried the package into the KUNG and laid it on the floor. At that moment the light was on in the KUNG. Budanov entered the KUNG. The distance from the place where he was (in the tent) to Budanov’s KUNG was 8-10 meters, no more. All the time, after Budanov’s arrival, three people from the crew of his BMP stood near the KUNG.

Volume 10, l. d. 104-108; volume 5, l. 99-102

Mishurov E.G. questioned as a witness. - a former soldier of military unit 13206, testified that he went on duty in the tent of the beginning. headquarters at 2 am. I saw that two crew members of Budanov’s BMP were standing near Budanov’s KUNG. At about 3.30 the BMP drove away from the KUNG. At about 5.50 the BMP returned to the unit and stood not far from the KUNG.

Volume 10, l. 130—138

Witness Viktor Alekseevich Koltsov testified that he served in military unit 13206 under a contract from February 1, 2000. At night 26.03. 2000 stood guard as a sentry guarding the pit where the company commander was located. He took up his post at about 11 p.m. At night, Budanov drove out of the camp in an infantry fighting vehicle. After about 30 minutes, the BMP returned to the unit; about 100 meters from the BMP parking lot, Budanov shouted to the driver: “Turn off the lights.” The BMP approached the KUNG with its headlights off. Then I heard the back door of the BMP slam, then the door of the KUNG opened. When I left my post and went into my tent, I saw the stoker. Makarshanov's headquarters. He said that “the commander brought the woman again.”

Volume 5, l. 12-13

Witness Aleksandr Mikhailovich Saifullin testified that he served in military unit 13206 since August 1999. Since the end of January 2000, he served as a stoker at Budanov’s KUNG. Around 5-5.15 on March 27, he went into the commander’s KUNG to keep the fire going in the stove. Budanov was lying on the right lounger, and not, as usual, on the far one. The carpet on the floor was shifted and bristling. The clock that hung above Budanov’s bed stood near the right bed, on the floor, closer to the exit. The curtain covering the sleeping compartment was pulled back slightly, and he saw that Budanov’s bed was not made. Budanov was sleeping. At about 7 am he came to KUNG, poured a bucket for the commander to wash, Budanov said to come at 7.15. The commander said to restore order in the KUNG and, pointing to the bed, ordered the blanket and all the linen there to be changed. He, Saifullin, began cleaning and noticed that the blanket on the bed was wet. The spot was located approximately 20 cm from the foot, on the edge adjacent to the wall. Lifting the blanket, he discovered a yellow spot 15 by 15 cm on the sheet. He changed his underwear. Then Budanov gave him an hour of time and ordered him to do a thorough cleaning of the KUNG. When he took the linen from the distant trestle bed from Budanov's KUNG, the left corner of the sheet was wet.

Volume 5, l. d. 21-26; 131—134

During the inspection on March 27, 2000, of the KUNG building where Budanov lived, it was established that there was a mattress on the bed farthest from the entrance. The mattress is wet towards the middle and there is a smell of urine.

Volume 5, l. 27-39

During the investigation, bed linen and a blanket from the bed were confiscated from Budanov's KUNG. The linen was included in the case as evidence. An examination of the sheets revealed yellow stains on them.

Volume 5, l. d. 48-50; 51—53

According to the conclusion of a forensic biological examination, on the sheets... (The following paragraph from the text of the indictment was removed. - Ed.)

Volume 7, l. 35-39

Witness Valery Vasilyevich Gerasimov testified that from March 5 to April 20, 2000, he acted as commander of the West group. On the morning of March 27, he learned from the commandant of Urus-Martan that a girl had been kidnapped from Tanga at night, and suspicions fell on the soldiers. He contacted the commanders of three regiments, including the 160th tank Budanov, and ordered the girl to be returned within 30 minutes. He himself, together with General Verbitsky Alexander Ivanovich, first went to the 245th regiment, then to the 160th. In 160, Budanov met him personally, saying that everything was in order in the regiment, nothing could be found out about the girl. Together with Verbitsky I went to Tangi, where the population had gathered at that moment. From the explanation of the girl’s father it followed that a colonel came to the village at night with soldiers in an infantry fighting vehicle, wrapped the girl in a blanket and took her away. They know this colonel - he is the commander of a tank regiment. He and Verbitsky didn't believe it at first. We returned to the regiment from the village, Budanov was absent. He ordered measures to be taken to detain Budanov. Budanov was detained. After his arrest, Budanov was taken to Khankala. In the evening of the same day, the driver-mechanic of the BMP (the one who went to the village) admitted that on the night of March 27 they brought the girl and dragged her into Budanov’s KUNG. Two hours later Budanov called them, the girl was already dead. Budanov ordered the corpse to be taken away and buried. On the morning of March 28, the body was dug up, taken to the medical battalion, an examination was performed, the body was washed and taken to the parents.

Volume 7, l. 135—142

The interrogated witness Igor Vladimirovich Grigoriev testified that on March 27. 2000, upon arrival at the unit, Budanov ordered them to bring the girl, wrapped in a blanket, into his KUNG, and they themselves remained next to the KUNG and guarded it so that no one would enter. Budanov himself remained in KUNG with the girl. About 10 minutes later, when they left the KUNG, women’s screams were heard from there, Budanov’s voice was also heard, then music was heard from the KUNG. Women's screams continued to be heard from the KUNG for some time. In KUNG Budanov was with the girl for about 1.5-2 hours. About 2 hours later, Budanov called all three to the KUNG, where the naked woman they had brought was lying on the bed, her face was bluish. There was a blanket on the floor, in which they wrapped the girl when they took her from the house. Her clothes lay in a heap on the same blanket. Budanov ordered them to take the woman out and bury her so that no one would know. Which is what they did. Having wrapped the body in a blanket, they took the girl out in BMP No. 391 and buried the body, which they reported to Budanov on the morning of March 27.

Volume 3, l. d. 151-160; 161—170

Interrogated on October 17, 2000, Grigoriev explained that 10-20 minutes after they left the KUNG, Budanov began shouting, but he did not hear what exactly. There were also several screams from the girl, screams characteristic of fear. When they entered the KUNG at Budanov’s call, they saw a naked girl lying on a trestle bed with no signs of life. She didn't have any clothes on. She was lying on her back, face up. There was a blanket on the floor, and on the blanket were the girl’s clothes - panties, a jacket, something else. The girl had bruises on her neck, as if she had been strangled by the throat. Budanov, pointing at her, with a strange expression on his face, said: “This is a bitch for you for Razamakhnin and for the guys who died at the height.”

Volume 5, l. 64-80

An examination of Kungaeva’s corpse revealed the following injuries: abrasions and hemorrhages located on the front surface of the neck in its upper third, hemorrhages in the soft tissues of the neck, cyanosis, puffiness of the face, pinpoint hemorrhages in the skin of the face, conjunctiva of the eyes, oral mucosa, under the pleura and epicardium ; bruises in the right infraorbital region, on the inner surface of the right thigh, a wound on the transitional fold of the conjunctiva of the right eye, hemorrhages in the mucous membrane of the vestibule of the mouth and gums, the upper jaw on the left. A corpse without clothes. Clothing was found next to the corpse: a woolen, knitted jacket. The jacket has rips (cuts) on the back. Cotton skirt, one side seam is torn; the yellow-white T-shirt on the back is torn (cut) along the entire length, the bra is beige, the strap at the back is cut (torn), the panties are beige cotton.

Volume 5, l. 80—88, 89—93

The conclusion of the forensic medical examination of the corpse of Kungaeva E.V. 22 dated 30.04. 2000 established: intravital injuries found on the neck of the corpse. These injuries resulted from compression of the neck by a hard object(s) with a limited surface area. These damages could have occurred within the period and under the circumstances specified in the descriptive part of this resolution. The cause of Kungaeva’s death was compression of the neck with a blunt hard object, which led to the development of asphyxia. The bruises found on Kungaeva’s corpse (on the face, left thigh), hemorrhages in the mucous membrane of the vestibule of the mouth, and a wound to the right eye were caused by the impact of a blunt hard object(s) with a limited surface. The type of damaging action was a blow. These injuries occurred intravitally and could have occurred within the period and under the circumstances specified in the descriptive part of this resolution.

Volume 6, l. 44-46

Interrogated as a witness by the investigator of military unit 20102, captain of justice Aleksey Viktorovich Simukhin, testified that on March 27, 2000, he received instructions to bring Budanov to the take-off pad of military unit 13206 to transport the latter to Khankala. On the way, Budanov was very excited, asking him what he should do, what to say, what to do. On the morning of March 28, 2000, he, Simukhin, as part of the investigative team, left to carry out investigative actions with the participation of witness Egorov to discover Kungaeva’s corpse. Egorov independently indicated the place where Kungaeva was buried. I would like to note that the burial place was very carefully camouflaged, hidden by turf, and if Egorov had not indicated where the victim was buried, it would have been impossible to visually detect this place at that time. The corpse in the grave was in a semi-sitting position, as if “an embryo in the womb of a woman,” the corpse was completely naked.

VICTIM BAGREV ROMAN VITALIEVICH,

Born 02/12/1975, native of Nikopol, Dnepropetrovsk region, Ukrainian SSR, deputy. beginning headquarters of the tank battalion, military unit 13206, st. Lieutenant testified as follows. From October 1, 1999, as part of the 160th Regiment, he took part in the counter-terrorist operation. He did not have any personal accounts with Budanov and Fedorov. On March 20, 2000, the reconnaissance company arrived from Komsomolskoye to Tangi. The regiment announced a competition among units to see which company had better order and living conditions. The anti-aircraft division took first place. Fedorov did not agree with the results and assured everyone that the reconnaissance company was still the best. To convince Budanov of this, on March 26, Fedorov insisted that a check of the company's location be carried out. After 18:00 Budanov, Fedorov, Silivanets, Arzumanyan arrived at the location. Budanov was drunk, but completely controlled himself. Fedorov was very drunk, spoke unclearly, and staggered. Fedorov began to persuade Budanov to check the company’s combat readiness. Three or more times Budanov refused Fedorov, but he continued to insist. Budanov gave in to Fedorov’s demands and gave him the command “At guns, ready for battle.” He, Bagreev, immediately ran towards the company’s trenches. Fedorov followed him. The vehicles reached the firing line. Budanov was at the communications center. He knew that in every vehicle on the delivery line there was always a fragmentation grenade shot on a tray. At that moment, there were no grounds for opening fire on the village, except for Fedorov’s order. After the BRMs took up positions, he gave the command to the crews to discharge a fragmentation round and load a shaped charge and fire one shot over the houses. When such a projectile is fired upward, it self-destructs without encountering an obstacle. The fragmentation charge does not have a self-destructor. While the crews were replacing the shells, there was a hitch. Machine 380 fired upward, over the houses of the village. Fedorov saw this, personally jumped onto the second BRM vehicle, gave the command to the gunner to shoot at Tanguy... Being dissatisfied with his, Bagreev’s, actions, Fedorov began to grab him by the clothes and insult him obscenely. Bagreev was called by Budanov. Arriving at the communications center, both Budanov and Fedorov were there. They beat him.

Volume 3, l. d. 145-150; volume 9, l. 19-20

An inspection revealed that in the southwest of the headquarters of military unit 13206, at a distance of 25 m from the regiment’s command post, at the time of March 27, 2000, there was a hole, on top of which 3 edged boards were laid. The pit is a depression in the ground: length 2.4 m, width 1.6 m, depth 1.3 m. The walls of the pit are lined with bricks, the bottom of the pit is earth.

Volume 5, l. 138—140, 141—158

Witness Dmitry Igorevich Pakhomov, a private, testified that on March 26, 2000, at about 8 p.m., Fedorov shouted at Bagreev: “I will teach you, puppy, to follow my orders.” Choice curses and insults were hurled at Bagreev. It was very wild to watch everything happening. Fedorov received orders to tie Bagreev up and put him in a hole. Previously, there had been cases in the regiment when a platoon tied up drunken contract soldiers and then put them in a pit, but for this to happen to a reconnaissance company commander was inexplicable. About an hour later, the platoon was again called by Budanov on alarm. When they arrived, Bagreev was already on the ground. Budanov and Fedorov began beating Bagreev again. After this, on Budanov’s command, Bagreev was again tied up and placed in a pit. Then Fedorov jumped down to Bagreev and began beating Bagreev in the pit. Bagreev at this time was screaming and moaning in the pit. Silivanets jumped into the pit and pulled Fedorov out. At about 2 o'clock he, Pakhomov, being in the tent, heard machine gun fire. As he learned, it was Suslov who shot to reason with Fedorov, who was trying to get to Bagreev.

Volume 7, l. 197—200

The criminal case on charges of Igor Vladimirovich Grigoriev, Artem Ivanovich Li-en-shou, Alexander Vladimirovich Egorov of not previously promised concealment of the murder of Kungaeva committed by Budanov, of committing a crime under Article 316 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, was terminated due to an amnesty.

Volume 1

According to the conclusion of an inpatient comprehensive forensic psychological and psychiatric examination of his mental state, Budanov was not in any temporary, painful mental disorder or in a state of pathological or physiological affect during the period of the act charged against him against Bagreev. At the time of the murder of Kungaeva, Budanov was in a short-term, transient, situationally determined psycho-emotional state of cumulative affect, could not fully understand the actual nature and significance of his actions and exercise their voluntary volitional regulation and control.

BASED ON THE FOREGOING, THE following are ACCUSED:

BUDANOV Yuri Dmitrievich, FEDOROV Ivan Ivanovich.

P.S.

Just one detail from what was not included in the indictment. Remember the episode when Budanov and Fedorov came to check the order in the reconnaissance company? Even before the “combat readiness check”? So, upon entering one of the officers’ tents, Budanov noticed a mess. He took out a grenade and threw it into the burning stove. The lieutenants jumped out and remained alive. The episode was withdrawn from the charge only due to the fact that no one died...